Big Brothers And History

March 2, 2018 India , Opinion , OPINION/NEWS

AFP photo



Ananya S Guha



In the present situation in India, what history do we look forward to or chart out? Historical mappings have contours defined not so by events, but events shaping destinies of communities and countries. Will history say that a movie was attempted to be banned because some rogue elements thought that it was insulting to a particular community? Or that three industrialists left the country because they defrauded banks? The present situation determines the future. Is history the future, when does it end?


The twenty century is battle scarred, nations playing wars and proxy wars, children dying in them and then nations pursuing what is called in diplomatic parlance, strategies. The world is torn asunder with wars in the Middle East, threat of war in the Pacific Peninsula, everyday firing across the Indian and Pakistani borders, the Korean American diatribes, Islamic terrorism aided by nations. In such situations the word peace is almost anathema. Cleverer expressions abound: diplomatic talks, negotiating table, etc. The holocaust of a war does not terrorize, it is taken for granted. The players are the nuclear tested nations, the victims multiply. History sears an uncouth head, withdraws temporarily while political happenings all over the world hold center stage. News implodes and explodes, television channels burst at the seams. And there is of course trade and bilateral talks, signatures impound nations, poverty takes a back seat and watches quietly like an impostor. The third world war may happen anytime? No it won’t, it is happening over and over again, it must have reached the hundredth.


Nations struggle for survival. Maldives. Will big brother intervene? Big brother is quietly ‘watching’. Other bigger brothers are watching over big brother India. India has a co big brother ,China, who is watching and sometimes snapping and molly cuddling India’s sworn enemy. Is history writing or recording all this? That the two Korea(s) a divided house try to conjoin sullenly with the biggest brother monitoring, appraising, chiding?


Let us pause and focus on Indian history. Do we have a redefined nationalism? Are the historians writing this definition and poring over ancient scripts? Are the text books, new replacing the old? Are we fashioning, designing, redesigning a new history? Why? Because the old was rotten. A monument is a grave don’t you know you idiots. So build temples and destroy mosques. That is the new age history. Grab all the votes, so that they understand this pulsating new age philosophy? Don’t you know it is a globalized world and a cashless society? No cash please, only machines. The slums grow. The PM says thousands of houses have been built. We blink. Where are the houses. In the moon says a voice.


In the meantime Big Brother and cousin pats us on the head. Great country. So diverse, but you shouldn’t have increased your export/ import duties. Cut it out he snaps. We ogle at his splendid mimicry.


Another Big Brother suddenly calls for suspension of activities (bombing, killing) in a country she has intervened to protect and also to rub shoulders with the other big brother.


What will history say of the Middle East? That it is a playground of Big Brothers, with people splitting like atoms. Small Brothers don’t know. Keep quiet. We know. We can’t speak. Double speak is dangerous it is an Orwellian crime.


So will history wait till all the Big Brothers superannuate? And finally will history please look at Peace?





Ananya S Guha

Ananya S Guha was born and brought up in Shillong, North East India. He has seven collections of poetry and his poems have been published worldwide. They have also been featured in several anthologies. He is also a columnist, critic and editor. He now is a Regional Director at the Indira Gandhi National Open University and holds a doctoral degree on the novels of William Golding.

Editor review


No Comments Yet!

You can be first to comment this post!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.